top of page

Gothic structure was first opened in 1876, but closed in 1995. It's seen riots, fires and the execution of nearly 100 prisoners through either hanging or electrocution.


Mark, Tina, Amanda & James  (Southern Paranormal Society NC)

 West Virginia Penitentiary 
 ​Moundsville, WV

JULY 28, 2012

PRISON HISTORY

The prison at Joliet provided the prototype for the West Virginia Penitentiary. It was an imposing stone structure fashioned in the castellated Gothic architectural style (adorned with turrets and battlements, like a castle). Only the dimensions of West Virginia's facility would differ; it would be approximately one-half the size of Joliet.

No architectural drawings of the West Virginia Penitentiary have been discovered, so an understanding of the plan developed by the Board of Directors must be obtained through their 1867 report, which details the procurement of a title for ten acres of land and a proposal to enclose about seven acres. On the north side would be a street 60 feet in width, and on the west 140 feet for street and yard to the front buildings.

The prison yard would be a parallelogram 682 1/2 feet in length, by 352 1/2 feet in width, enclosed by a stone wall 5 feet in thickness at the bottom, 2 1/2 feet at the top, with foundation 5 feet below the surface, and wall 25 inches thick. At each of the corners of this wall would be large turrets, for the use of the guards, with inside staircases. Guardrooms would be above on a level with the top of the main. The superintendent's house and cell buildings would be so placed that the rear wall of each would form part of the west wall.

W.VA. PEN INMATES RIOT; 12 HOSTAGES BEING HELD

Moore Audience Denied

By JIM COCHRAN

News-Register Staff Writer

January 2, 1986

Bulletin!

Several relatives of those currently being held hostage by inmates at the West Virginia State Penitentiary at Moundsville are demanding to speak with Gov. Arch A. Moore Jr. in what was reported to be an impassioned plea for the safety of loved ones held inside the 100-year-old maximum-security prison.

Speaking to the news media briefly this morning, officials on the scene revealed that one of the hostages, Bill Henderson, a guard, had contacted his wife, Melanie, saying, "That if they (police officials) storm the place, someone will die."

Meanwhile, there has been no official word on the demands the inmates are making for the release of the hostages other than a request to meet with Moore.

Negotiations continued late this morning with inmates at the West Virginia Penitentiary at Moundsville who Wednesday evening gained control of a portion of the state's maximum-security facility.

Twelve persons - 11 corrections officers and one food service personnel - are being held by a group of inmates.

Two other hostages were released on Wednesday evening and the other this morning.

Although no formal demands have been made by the inmates, three employees - Paul Kirby, who heads the medical division, David Fromhart, a sections chief and Jeff Fromhart, a counselor - have met with the inmates several hours since the 5:30 pm takeover.

The inmates reportedly want to talk with Gov. Arch Moore Jr., who has said through his press secretary John Price that he will not talk with the inmates until the hostages have been released and the institution is returned back to correctional officials.

Moore was in Florida on a vacation at the time of the takeover.

One inmate has died. He was Kent Slie, serving a life term for murder from Putnam County. Slie was born in New Martinsville.

The two hostages released were Mike Coleman and Eddie Littell. Coleman reportedly had suffered chest pains and Littell had an injured arm. Neither was admitted to the hospital.

The hostages have been identified as: Patrick Glascock, Robert Hill, Robert Johnson, Mike Smith, John Wilson, Bill Wright, Robert Jones, Sanford Clegg, Leslie Howearth, Russell Lorentz, Joe Hill (all correctional officers). Bill Henderson, a food service employee, was also taken.

A new food service firm, Serv-A Mation, began operation Wednesday; the former food server had employed Henderson.

The inmates, who began their takeover during the supper hour Wednesday, have control of the southern section of the institution. They reportedly broke into the control unit, which houses the most hardened criminals.

In addition to the control unit, the men involved in the siege reside in the New Wall and P. & R. units. The men have access to the dining hall and the infirmary.

Wednesday evening state police from sections of the state were called to the institution, and appeared in riot gear, along with all off-duty correctional officers, Marshall County sheriff's deputies and Moundsville City police.

The inmates seized the prison in a riot inside the dining hall while the evening meal was served.

"We don't want this any more that you do," one inmate yelled out a window. "You quit treating us like dogs, this wouldn't happen."

"We want better living conditions, better facilities and better medical conditions. They treat us just like dogs in here. This ain't going to go on."

State police said between 125 and 200 inmates out of a prison population of about 740 were involved.

Authorities had control of the prison guard towers. Spotlights played on the prison walls and there was the occasional sound of breaking glass. Smoke drifted above the prison walls at times.

More than six hours after the riot broke out, leaders of the rebellion began compiling a list of demands to be presented to the warden over walkie-talkies taken from the captive guards.

There were no reports of injuries and none of the prison's 742 convicts had escaped, officials said, but 100 police in riot gear ringed the prison to prevent a breakout while a large crowd of townspeople milled about and stood on porches across the street.

Bill Wallace, one of the bystanders outside the prison, said he heard inmates shouting demands out windows for "better medical services, better living quarters, a pizza and some women."

"I feel sorry for the poor people in there but if they didn't do what they did, they wouldn't be in there," Wallace said.

Warden Jerry Hedrick told reporters at an impromptu news conference outside the prison that the takeover started in the dining hall but that the inmates appeared to have abandoned it for two cell blocks in the south end of the facility.

"At this particular time they are going to send a list of demands," Hedrick said. "We will take a look at that but that is all we are doing now."

"They pretty much have the run of the place, right now. Everything is peaceful. I don't know how well organized it is."

The warden said the prisoners had set no deadlines and had made no threats that he was aware of.

He said the inmates did not get any weapons from the guards but added, "of course they manufacture weapons in there."

The prison had "about 30" guards on duty at the time of the takeover, Hedrick said.

Corrections Commissioner A. V. Dodrill rejected demands by riot leaders to meet with Moore.

"They said they would not talk to anyone until they talk to Gov. Moore, but I told the staff he would not be available." Said William Whyte, executive aide to Dodrill.

When the inmates were denied an audience with Moore, some took off their clothes and set them on fire, officials said.

Officials said one of the hostages was an employee of Morrison Food Service, the firm under contract to prepare prison meals. The prison, under orders to make vast reforms, was the scene of a 1973 riot that left one inmate dead and two others wounded. Six years ago, 15 convicts staged a mass escape in which an off-duty sate trooper and one of the fugitives were killed.

MOUNDSVILLE PRISONERS RIOT; HOLDING 5 GUARDS HOSTAGE

Wheeling News-Register

March 20, 1973

At least two convicts were hospitalized and five guards at the West Virginia Penitentiary at Moundsville were being held hostage during a full-scale riot that broke out at the prison this morning.

There was a report from the prison shortly after noon that the rioting convicts threatened to shoot the five hostages if State Police or prison guards fired gunshots or tear gas at them.

A fire in the basement of the prison was reported to be burning out of control at 12:30 pm.

State Police armed with gas masks entered the Penitentiary and were stationed around the outside to block off streets to pedestrian and car traffic.

"They're tearing hell out the place," said Howard Riggs of 2 Kermit Ct., who lives at the southern tip of the Penitentiary.

At 10:30 am the convicts apparently set fire to the Penitentiary as Riggs reported he could see smoke coming from inside the walls. Moundsville City fire trucks were still inside the prison walls at noon but Riggs reported the smoke had subsided by that time.

Two of the three inmates taken to the Reynolds Memorial Hospital were reported suffering from stab wounds. There was no immediate report on their condition.

Penitentiary Warden William O. Wallace confirmed that five guards were being held hostage by the convicts but declined to reveal their identity until their families are notified.

Riggs said the rioting could easily be heard from outside the prison walls. "There was glass breaking and a lot of cussing and hollering. The convicts were hollering obscenities to people outside," Riggs stated.

The first report of what triggered the riot was that a group of convicts overpowered a guard and took his keys to the solitary confinement section of the prison. There they released Bobby Gene Jarvis, the convict who has been indicted and is awaiting trial for the murder last October of prison guard, William Quilliams.

Another report was that a convict identified as Paul Ellis Davis, who has killed two inmates while confined to the Penitentiary, then released 17 other prisoners from confinement and these inmates then triggered the riot and eventually took five guards hostage.

A member of the construction crew, which was ordered away from the Penitentiary when the riot broke out, identified Davis. The construction crew was working on improvements at the prison. Prisoners from the maximum-security section of the prison were demanding to talk with a representative of Gov. Arch A. Moore, Jr.

Wallace said that Moore's special assistant Norman Yost had left Charleston by helicopter at 11:30 am and was expected in Moundsville shortly after noon.

Wallace said that the men have not revealed their grievance but according to one report the riot began early this morning when a guard was taking a group of prisoners to the bath area and a prisoner identified only as Davis reportedly jumped a guard, and grabbed his keys.

The prisoners barricaded themselves in the maximum-security section of the prison and have threatened to kill the five hostages if any shots or tear-gas are fired into the area.

Tension mounted around the prison as Wallace, the State Police, guards and Marshall County Sheriff's deputies wearing shields and hard hats brandished shotguns and rifles.

Traffic has been cordoned off around the prison, and smoke still poured from a south entrance on Jefferson Avenue at noon.

Spectators outside could see the smashed windows inside the prison.

It was estimated by officials that about 35 "hard-core" convicts were involved in the rioting and taking of the five hostages.

Approximately 170 law enforcement officers - state and local - were on the scene.

Wallace said the inmates in the prison had volunteered to try to extinguish the fire burning out of control in the prison basement, if guards would put a hose inside.

However, one guard said that only old clothing was stored in the burning section, but that it was impossible to determine how bad the fire was getting. At 12:30 pm prisoners began again to break windows in the prison.

3 KILLERS ESCAPE PEN

By JIM COCHRAN

The Intelligencer Staff

February 20, 1992

Three murderers serving life terms escaped from the West Virginia Penitentiary in Moundsville Wednesday.

They tunneled their way out of the maximum-security facility in broad daylight.

Tommie Lee Mollohan, 49; David Williams, 33 and Frederick Hamilton, 34, who were discovered missing after 3 p.m., were still on the loose Wednesday night.

Warden Carl Legursky and M/Sgt. D.P. Lake of the State Division of Public Safety said the escapees should be considered dangerous.

Legursky said he was told by the Moundsville police department that a hole was discovered outside the walls on the east side of the prison at Ninth Street at about 3:15 p.m. Prison clothing and a ladder were found in the hole.

Legursky said an emergency lockdown was instituted and it was found that Mollohan, Williams and Hamilton were missing.

City, county and state police immediately set up roadblocks leading from Moundsville and police agencies throughout West Virginia, Ohio and Pennsylvania were notified.

The dispatcher at the Moundsville detachment of the West Virginia State Police said state troopers, sheriff's deputies, police officers and officers from the Department of Natural Resources set up road blocks at strategic spots in the Northern Panhandle.

Those spots included the Interstate 470 Bridge in Wheeling near Bethlehem; the Fort Henry Bridge in Wheeling; the bridge across the Ohio at 12th Street in Moundsville; and various routes leading from the Moundsville area, the State Police dispatcher said.

Chief Deputy Art Watson of the Marshall County Sheriff's Department said his officers were manning roadblocks on WV 2.

"There was a big traffic jam from checking traffic in the Glen Dale area at one time due to the roadblock," Watson said shortly after 7 p.m., "But it's dissipated by now."

Lake said initially 23 state troopers from Northern Panhandle detachments were summoned to Moundsville, and that at least 15 others would be arriving later in the evening or early Thursday morning.

"The state police, sheriff's department, the Division of Natural Resources, city police agencies and the prison are working jointly in an effort to recapture these men," Lake said.

"Throughout the night we will be manning road blocks, having roving patrols and following up on any leads."

However, he added, "We have not had as many leads as I had hoped to have. We want to get these men back behind bars."

A search dog was brought in to assist in the manhunt; it got the escapees' scent from the prison jacket that was found in the hole.

Mollohan and Hamilton had access to digging tools because they worked in the greenhouse, said Legursky. A mattock from the Greenhouse was found in the tunnel along with a homemade pipe wrench ladder and a red jacket worn by inmates.

The warden said the inmates should have been wearing khaki clothing, but he doesn't know if they had smuggled out civilian clothing.

Legursky said the tunnel began in the greenhouse, which has a dirt floor. "They had the area well camouflaged with shelves and other greenhouse items," he said.

Legursky said the hole in the greenhouse was about 8 feet deep. The warden said they then tunneled horizontally about 32 feet, going under the wall. Once on the other side of the wall, they dug about 16 feet up to Washington Avenue from where they exited the hole.

Although there is a tower next to where the men tunneled out, Legursky said it was not manned and the inmates knew that.

The warden said in the past six to eight months correctional officers have found four other tunnels that had been started, but until this time no one had escaped.

"In fact," he said, "this is the first escape from within the institution since I became warden…

"Incidentally, last Friday (Feb. 14) two inmates attempted to scale the wall, but were spotted by an officer in a tower.

"We usually get some word on any attempted escapes, but this one shocked me because we had no knowledge," the warden said.

"We had no reason to suspect these men were up to anything. They were living in general population and had not been a problem of late," Legursky said.

A native of Miami, FL, Mollohan, 49 was convicted Nov. 28, 1973 for first-degree murder in Kanawha County and was sentenced Jan. 7, 1974 to life in prison. Mollohan was retired in Kanawha County on Sept. 30, 1981 and received a sentence of life without mercy.

He is 5 feet 10 inches tall and weighs 180 pounds. He has a ruddy complexion, brown hair and blue eyes.

Williams, 33, of Welch, WV is serving a life without mercy sentence form McDowell County for first-degree murder. He was convicted July 23, 1981. Originally he was charged with first-degree arson and robbery, but these charges were later dismissed, and he was re-sentenced in McDowell County on Sept. 1, 1983 for first-degree murder, receiving a life without mercy sentence.

Williams is 5 feet 9 inches tall and weighs 183 pounds. He has brown hair and blue eyes.

Hamilton, 34, received sentences for malicious wounding, first-degree murder, conspiracy to murder, kidnapping and two counts of armed robbery. He is serving three consecutive sentences, a 10-year consecutive sentence, a 15-year concurrent sentence and two 10-year sentences. He was convicted in Grant County in 1978.

He is 6 feet tall, and weighs 175 pounds. He has brown hair and green eyes.

Two former wardens of the Penitentiary said the tunnel escape must have been a well-planned, well-orchestrated affair. Donald Bordenkircher, currently the chief of Moundsville Police Department as well as a former Marshall County Sheriff, said, "They've tried it (tunneling out of the Penitentiary) before."

He said the escape route was a "beautiful tunnel and had a very good ladder leading to it from inside the pen."

He also said the project probably "took quite a while to dig."

Ohio County Sheriff Art McKenzie, another former warden at the Penitentiary, said the tunnel had to be part of a well-planned escape attempt.

"The nice thing about a tunnel is you know you're going to try breaking out. It takes a while and you have to make other plans in conjunction with it," McKenzie said.

Those other plans may have involved outside help with a waiting car, he said.

He said some tunnels were attempted during his stint as warden, "but they never came to anything."

Legursky said that once Wednesday's emergency countdown was completed, the institution returned to as he described it, "near normal" in such a situation. He said, "We will be back to normal tomorrow.(today)."

ESCAPEES HAD HELP

By JIM COCHRAN

The Intelligencer

April 5, 1988

West Virginia Penitentiary Warden Jerry Hedrick said Monday prison officials strongly believe the three inmates who escaped Sunday night had transportation waiting for them once they reached the street in front of the facility.

The warden said tracking dogs from Belmont County were brought to the institution shortly after the men were discovered missing late Sunday, and the dogs tracked the scents of the men across the street into the middle of the parking lot of the Delf Norona Museum where they lost the trail.

All three inmates - Tommie Mollohan, 46, Bobby Dean Stacy, 36 and David Williams, 29 - were serving life sentences without mercy for murder.

The warden said none of the escapees had weekend visitors.

Hedrick said that during the weekend Mollohan had claimed his eyes were irritated and he went to the infirmary for medical attention.

The warden said during the distribution of medications Sunday night that the escape was detected. He said one of the three was not in his cell, and as a result an emergency count was instituted and during the count it was determined that two other inmates were also unaccounted for.

Hedrick said, "Something wasn't right with security, something was overlooked, and when this happens the inmates will tell you."

However, the warden said during a news conference Monday, "It has been business as usual today."

Hedrick explained that the men, all of whom are assigned to inside maintenance work, made their way into an elevator shaft in the infirmary. They then knocked a hole in a wall to gain entry to the "stoop" area, and from there made their way to an elevator shaft in the Old Administration Building.

"Once inside the elevator shaft in the Old Administration Building they had access to the entire unit which is unoccupied," Hedrick said. He added, "They then made their way to a second story window and with the use of a metal pipe and a telephone type cable lowered themselves to the ground, in an area hidden from the street and the nearest tower by huge ventilation unit which has yet to be installed on the roof of the North Hall housing unit."

The prison yard is surrounded by a chain link fence, but two sections have been converted into a gate to permit outside workman access, it was through this gate that the inmates fled the prison grounds by cutting the lock with bolt cutters which they had taken from the "stoop" area where the tools are secured.

Hedrick said he believed the three men had a certain bond, since they worked together and two of them were housed in the same tier in the Now Wall housing unit.

State Police Issued a statewide all-points bulletin after it was determined the men had escaped. Some 40 law enforcement personnel searched and manned roadblocks in Marshall County with the roadblocks remaining intact until daybreak on Monday. Law enforcement agencies in Eastern Ohio and Western Pennsylvania were alerted.

Hedrick described the escapees as dangerous because of the nature of their crimes.

ESCAPEES REPORTED DANGEROUS

By STEVE WATERSON

The Intelligencer Staff

November 17, 1988

Although the two inmates who escaped Wednesday afternoon from the West Virginia Penitentiary in Moundsville may have been model prisoners, they both were convicted of brutal murders and are considered extremely dangerous.

The two escapees are Freddie Rakes, 29 and Dickie Wimmer, 36 both serving life prison sentences without chance for parole.

On a September evening in 1981, Rakes and two accomplices, a man and a juvenile girl, decided to rob a Lincoln County man named Ernie Neal, who was in his 70's and lived by himself on a farm.

Rake, who knew the old man, knocked on Neal's door. Rakes said his car was struck in a ditch, and asked Neal to get his tractor to pull the car out, and as the pair walked toward Neal's barn Rakes hit the old man over the head with a rake. Rakes then shot Neal several times and ran over the old man with a truck, twice.

 

Rake, who knew the old man, knocked on Neal's door. Rakes said his car was struck in a ditch, and asked Neal to get his tractor to pull the car out, and as the pair walked toward Neal's barn Rakes hit the old man over the head with a rake. Rakes then shot Neal several times and ran over the old man with a truck, twice.

It was three days before Neal's family found his body. Rakes and his accomplices fled to North Carolina, but were apprehended and brought back to West Virginia. During his trial, it was determined Rakes had been the one who actually committed the murder, and his accomplices were allowed to plead guilty to lesser crimes.

During the trial it was also determined that Rakes altered the shotgun shells he used to shoot Neal so that the bullets would make a harder impact. Testimony from the state medical examiner revealed Neal died from loss of blood caused by the first shotgun blast - to his knee - and that the old man was still alive when Rakes ran over him in the truck.

In addition to his life-without-mercy sentence for killing Neal, Rakes was given a 75-year-sentence for the violence he used in robbing the old man. As if to ensure Rakes never would be set free, the judge ordered the 75-year-sentence be served after the life term.

Wimmer was upset because his relationship with his wife was faltering, went to an Oceana apartment where she and their two children were staying on January 15, 1979. After a confrontation with his estranged wife, Wimmer shot her to death. He also shot to death his 6-year-old daughter and 3-year-old son.

Wimmer then went to a nearby apartment and told the residents to call an ambulance, saying his wife and children were sick. Medical personnel called police after seeing the trio had been shot, and Wimmer resisted police when they arrived. He initially was charged with obstructing a police officer, but that subsequently was changed to three counts of murder.

Authorities and witnesses who testified against Rakes and Wimmer have been notified of the pair's escape, for a state police trooper said Wimmer had threatened those who testified against him.

W. VA. PENITENTIARY

Wheeling Register, April 18, 1886.

OUR INSTITUTIONS.

An Interesting History of the West Virginia Penitentiary.

Its Management, Condition, and Inmates -- Tales of Lawless Life Told by Life Prisoners, Etc.

Special Correspondence of the Sunday Register.
[Concluded]

MOUNDSVILLE, W. VA., April 16 -- In resuming a history of the West Virginia penitentiary and its workings it will be apropos to give the names and positions of the different offices and guards in order that the reader may more readily understand its management and conditions.

 

OFFICERS.

The whole institution is under the management of a superintendent and assistant superintendent, subject only to the rules and regulations of the prison and the Board of Directors.

The superintendent and his assistant, Col. Peck and Capt. Wilkinson, have been already introduced to the reader.

Next in order may come the guardmen, which consist of T. J. Johnson, Capt.; J. R. Perry, hall guard, and J. F. Ferguson, W. Fitzsimmons, E. Ryan, J. C. Israel, Samuel Ferguson, Fred Bauer, Jas. Wood, W. H. Wiltis, H. J. Monahan, George O'Neal, John Doran, C. G. Reynolds, R. W. Maupin, J. Monahan, C. H. McCarraher, and H. E. Hogan, night guard. W. B. Humphreys, Esq. , is superintendent of the works in the shops.

Major C. W. Wickham is chief engineer, and has held that position for a long series of years. The Major is well-known throughout the State, and is certainly a very popular fellow. His Falstaffian figure, good-natured face, and extreme delight in getting the job on "the other fellow" is a solid fact not easily forgotten by the other fellow, (until he gets even with the "coon.")

 

THEIR LABOR.

To return to the subject in hand. Within the gloomy walls are situated a number of long brick buildings, within which the convicts perform their daily tasks. They are sold under contract of a series of years to different firms. The Webster Wagon Works is the largest concern, and employs most of the men. Here the men, after the morning meal, are marched into the different shops; the blacksmith, paint, machine and wood works. They have each man a task to perform, which is estimated at two-thirds of an ordinary day's work. After the accomplishment of their task they are allowed to stand at ease, rest beside their benches, or, if they choose, can still continue to work until the hour for knocking off arrives. For all extra work they are allowed a certain amount, and in a number of instances, your reporter found that prisoners gain extra pay in order to secure certain luxuries, such as reading matter, &c.

 

THEIR TASKS.

In order to learn whether their tasks were heavy or not, your reporter was allowed to ask one of the prisoners a few questions upon the subject. He selected Raymond, who had been sent up for a number of years for post office robbery. After the men had retired to their cells and the clang of the heavy iron bars of which each one closed a tier of cells, had ceased ringing with its cold steely sound in his ears, the reporter went to the door of the cell occupied by Raymond and said:

"Raymond, where do you work?"

In the laconic prison tones, which in long years of silent labor became second nature, he replied:

"In the wagon factory."

"How many pieces have been allotted you as a task?"

"Twelve."

"How many did you make to-day?"

"Twenty-three."

"How many could you readily make in work hours?"

"Two tasks."

Raymond's cell, like a number of others, was fitted up at the farther end with shelves, upon which were piled books, papers and pictures. By this means the more intelligent prisoners while away the tedium of the hours of evening before the command to "put out the lights and retire" is given.

 

MAKING WHIPS.

The broom factory and whip factories under the management of Messrs. Weaver & Bardall, are conducted upon the same principles. Here, however, the smaller and weaker of the prisoners, who could not stand the heavier labor, are employed. Each room has the appearance of a busy hive of bees. The long benchers in the whip factory are filled with men and boys, who are kept busy at making whips of all kinds, from the "dog whip," destined to fill the delicate hand and taper finger of the Boston belle, as she fastidiously glides along the fashionable promenades of the city of "Culcha and Baked Beans," accompanied by her skye terrier or her more hydrophobic spitz, to the long cattle whip of the cowboy on the Texas plains. Whips in all stages of composition, from the thin strips as long as one's hand to the finished oiled and varnished whip, ready to ship, are constantly going through process of manufacture.

 

OLD HABITS.

Among the convicts are many experts, whose handiwork are marvels of skill and schooled patience. Indeed, it would seem that after years of toil and confinement and with the means of obtaining an honest, honorable living and competence, these men would never return, but criminals glide back to their old haunts and old companions with a fatal facility. Let there be seemingly the fairest hope of reformation the frost work of new habits appears to melt away at the first fire of temptation. Victor Hugo exhibits a keen insight into human nature, when he makes Valjean rob the Savoyard of his two pence, even after the forgiveness and generosity of the good bishop. As an evidence of this there are a number of prisoners here who have been here before, and several now serving life sentences who have been sent a third time for some offence, which had it been the first or even the second offence, would have been perhaps for not more than two or three years, but the law, in its wisdom, dooms a man who has been convicted a third time in this State to a life sentence.

 

THE ENGINE ROOM.

Near the workshops stands the long engine house with its immense boilers and massive engines which drive all the machinery and pump up the water supply for the prison. This department is presided over by Major Wickham, who is one of the best engineers in the State. Under his supervision and care the huge machinery is kept polished and bright as a mirror.

 

BIG JOHN -- A VALUABLE PRISONER.

Under Mr. Wickham, the assistant engineer is Big John, a life convict. John is colored man whose sentence for life was passed 14 years ago for a crime the penalty of which now in the United States, would average, say 14 years. In giving me his history, all the officers agreed that John was the most faithful, reliable and honest prisoner they ever had. He was here when the present prison was built. He worked on the walls, cut the first stone and did more work, and all in workmanlike manner, than any outside free employe. Once, I am told, John with another prisoner was taken by a guard to the pumping station at the river. The guard was compelled to go back to the prison, I believe, and left John and his fellow convict, believing they would remain. The officer was detained longer than he expected, and one of the prisoners ran off. John ran to the prison and reported the escape of the prisoner. Of course, the man is treated as well as it is permitted. I made a rough estimate of the amount of money saved to the State by John's labor as mechanic and engineer, and arrived at the conclusion that he had saved not less than $10,000 since his incarceration. At all events it would have cost that much or more to have employed that amount of equally skilled labor. Before John's time the prison was surrounded by a high wooden fence. In 1867 several members of the notorious

 

JENNINGS GANG,

among whom was Frank Jennings, son of old John Jennings, Wetzel county's notorious marauder. Frank Jennings was the leading spirit in all the mutinies and insubordinations of the prison, and one night during a terrible storm, in which the fence blew down, he led twenty-six prisoners in a dash for liberty. They were fired upon and pursued and all captured except Jennings himself, who escaped to the old haunts of the gang in Wetzel county, on Coal run, but a few miles back of New Martinsville. The house of old John Jennings was always an objective point to escaped prisoners, and it was so carefully guarded, and having secret means of egress and entrance, that very few were ever captured. The crimes of this gang, John Jennings, his four boys, William, Thomas, Frank and Jack, Godard, Barcus, Cannon, Parker, Willard, the Van Horn woman and others, are still fresh in the minds of the older residents of Wetzel, Tyler, Marshall, Pleasants and other counties. The pursuit of the gang, capture of several of them, and finally the descent of the "Red Men," after a series of horrible murders committed by the gang, upon the lair of the leader, old John, and his death after a terrible struggle, their descent upon Lynn Camp, the burning of the houses inhabited by the gang, and the exodus of outlaws and criminal refugees by the light of the torch and flame of burning houses is matter well known to many.

But to return to the subject:

In the paint shop, where the bodies of the wagons are painted are several notorious offenders, chief among whom is perhaps,

 

W. S. DOUGLAS, AN EX EDITOR AND MARSHAL, OF TEXAS.

Douglas, who is a life prisoner, was sent up from Grant county for the murder of a young boy, a mail carrier. The details of the crime show it to have been revolting in its cold blooded, deliberate accomplishment. It seems the day of the murder several registered letters were put in the pouch carried by the boy and this knowledge came to the ears of Douglas, who waylaid and shot the boy, inflicting a serious but not fatal wound. The boy in endeavoring to escape the assassin ran his horse into St. Johns run and swam across, only to meet his murderer, who ran across a bridge and headed him off and deliberately murdered him as he came out of the water. Douglas had his trials, and was found guilty in both. Gen Flick was at one time retained by him, if I mistake not, but his crime was so great and the evidence to clear that nothing could be done to save him, and he was finally sentenced to the penitentiary for the period of his natural life. It may interest the newspaper fraternity to know that Douglas is the only one of their number who ever was sent to the West Virginia penitentiary for so base a crime. He told your reporter the story of his life, and the following brief outline covers the principal events of his history. He was born and raised in West Virginia, until, at the age of 15, when he went into a newspaper office as a "devil," (and he has been the incarnation of a veritable Pluto ever since). He learned to set type, became a compositor, afterward a "jour," and finally finding the field of journalism in West Virginia too narrow for his special talents emigrated to Texas. Being a man of pleasant address, and apparently a gentleman, there he formed the acquaintance and married an estimable young lady, by whom he had one child, which lived but three or four years and was shortly followed by its mother. He left that portion of Texas, went to Lampasas, and started a newspaper called the Lampasas Advertiser. Here he again married. Douglas was appointed a Deputy Sheriff, and performed the duty so well, especially that portion of it connect with capturing wild outlaws of the frontier, that when his time as Deputy Sheriff expired he was elected

 

MARSHAL.

As a Marshal there is no doubt that Douglas made his mark on more than one occasion, principally inscribed, no doubt, with 40 calliber bullets. He always brought in his man, but as often feet-foremost as with perpendicular, but one day he went out to arrest some one on a warrant, he followed probably his last trail (but one) of death. He returned to the little town of Lampasas, with his prisoner strapped to the back of a horse. But the prisoner was as dead as cold lead could make him. One story goes that the dead man had many friends who believed that he had been deliberately murdered and swore to avenge him. Another, but somewhat less plausible one was that the score keepers of the coroner's jury disagreed as to the number of bullet holes in the dead man, and the coolness that arose on that occasion gradually centered upon Douglas. Be that as it may, Douglas directly after the above occurrence left Texas for the mountains of West Virginia. He, like ninety-nine men out of the hundred in prison, declares his entire innocence of the crime attributed to him.

 

THOMAS, THE CHEROKEE,

is another life prisoner. He, with three others, among them a Chief "Gray Eagle," was sentenced by the Government for murder. The murders committed by these men were the killing of whites, for which crimes they were tried by the United States Courts. Had the murdered man been one of their own color and tribe they would have been tried in their own territory under Cherokee laws. These Indians were brought here several years ago, but the Government of prison life, broke the heart of his chief and two of his companions, and they died. They are buried within the prison walls, in one corner of the yard, and their spirits released from human bondage, started for the happy hunting grounds where the rattle of chains, the clanging of iron doors and the constant toil of daily existence is no longer known. The only one left, Charley Thomas, is a half breed, tall, muscular and powerful. He is one of the best blacksmiths in the shops; always prompt, obedient and attentive. Doubtless the memory of broad plains, the wild free life of the nation, often rushes upon his memory, but if so, he never mentions it, but goes on with his work, quietly and assiduously, day after day, and retires to his cell at night like the hundreds of others, apparantly glad that the hours of toil are over and the shades of night and rest and sleep are bringing him one more day nearer the goal of hope -- freedom -- death.

 

THE HOSPITAL.

A hospital is attached to the prison, to which all invalid prisoners are sent after examination by the prison physician. The hospital steward is, I believe, a certain doctor, a convict, who is a regularly educated physician. This disciple of Esculapius is an eccentric genius. One of his idiosyncrasies is, I belive, a fondness for appropriating other folks' horses. His weakness for horse flesh and disregard for the doctrine of meum and tuum brought suspicion upon him, and the last time the doctor got a corner on the horse market he lost his diploma and liberty both at one and the same time. He is considered one of the stubborn cases of the prison.

 

THE COSMOPOLITAN NATURE

of the prison is one of its peculiar features. All classes of society and many professions are represented. The ex-minister and pick-pocket work side by side, while the ex-legislator marks time with the sneak thief, and the ex-treasurer of some large institution sits elbow to elbow with the scum of the lowest purleus. There are no class distinctions and no preferences.

 

THE BAKERY

is presided over and managed by convicts, who make and bake all the provisions of the convicts. Everything in and about the bakery is clean and neat. There is no waste of material although there is plenty of everything. Next the bakery is

 

THE LAUNDRY,

which is manned by convicts also. The clothing of all the prisoners is here thoroughly cleansed and dried. So clean is everything that not the slightest speck of dirt can be found upon any garment. The soap is also made in the laundry by a convict from materials left from the prison bill of fare. When I went through the prison, Joe Paul, the unfortunate prisoner spoken of in my last letter, was foreman, I think, but his health has so badly failed, I learn that he has been removed to other and lighter work.

 

THE PRISON PET.

In the corridor at the door leading into the dining room covered with a leather case, stands the prison pet. It is a beautiful, nickle-mounted Gatling gun. Its roll of rifle muzzles point toward the door, and if a mutiny occur while the prisoners are all in the dining room a single guard could with one hand guide the muzzle, while with the other by turning a crank he could fill each emptied barrel with a fresh cartridge from the hopper at the top. A hailstorm of bullets would sweep across the dining room so fast and so true that not a living human being would be left standing, and this all could be done in less time than it takes to tell it. There will be no mutiny while the "Pet" "holds the fort."

With this paragraph I will close the description of the West Virginia Penitentiary. If the reader wishes to learn something of other institutions of the State he can be gratified at an early day by continuing the perusal of the SUNDAY REGISTER.

THE GREENBRIER GHOST
THE ONLY GHOST TO TESTIFY IN A MURDER TRIAL

From the 1999 September issue of Wonderful WV Magazine: http://www.wonderfulwv.com/archives/sept99/fea2.cfm

 An article about one of the "residents" that used to live at the 
former WV Penitentiary
 

By Katie Letcher Lyle

     

     A state highway mile marker a few miles west of Lewisburg declares the "only known case in which [the] testimony from [a] ghost helped convict a murderer." Drawn by the story of the "Greenbrier Ghost," I embarked on a search for the truth about a local legend based on certain events that occurred at the end of the 19th-century. The result is my book, The Man Who Wanted Seven Wives. The briefest form of the story is that told by the road marker: "Interred in a nearby cemetery is Zona Heaster Shue. Her death in 1897 was presumed natural until her spirit appeared to her mother to describe how she was killed by her husband Edward. Autopsy on the exhumed body verified the apparition's account. Edward, found guilty of murder, was sentenced to state prison."

     Near the end of January 1897, Zona Heaster Shue, who had been a popular young girl in Greenbrier County, and was now a bride of three months, was found dead at the bottom of the stairs leading to the second floor of the log house where she lived with her new husband. The body was discovered by a neighbor, a child of about 11 years, who did chores for her. Zona's body was taken 14 miles across the valley to her childhood home on Little Sewell Mountain, and buried three days later. At the time, there was no intimation in the local newspaper, The Greenbrier Independent, of anything unusual about the young woman's death. The physician who examined the body, Dr. George W. Knapp, announced that she "died of an everlasting faint." On January 30 he wrote in the death record in Lewisburg that she died of childbirth.

 

 The Richlands section of Greenbrier County, just west of Lewisburg, was a remote area, and the people were clannish. Zona's husband was not one of them, but a blacksmith from Pocahontas, the next county to the north. He was a newcomer to Greenbrier County, but from the beginning cut a wide swath, as he was from all reports good-looking and powerful, charismatic and boastful, and he attracted even more notice than most strangers. Furthermore, he had swept one of their own off her feet, and married her faster than anyone could say "Jack Robinson."

      Within a month of the burial, the dead girl's mother, Mary Jane Heaster, was telling neighbors that Zona's spirit had appeared four nights in a row to accuse the blacksmith of her violent death - to "tell on him" - to set the record straight about her dying. Word spread quickly that these visions had convinced Mary Jane that the husband - who called himself Edward, but was really named Erasmus Stribbling Trout Shue, and was known as Trout - had killed her daughter. In the weeks that followed Zona's death, there was a great deal of local gossip about the glamorous blacksmith, and some details of his past came to light that he had neglected to share with his new neighbors. Not only had he changed his name, he had also failed to mention that Zona had not been his first wife, nor even his second.

      Shue's first marriage, to Allie Estelline Cutlip in 1885, produced a child, Girta Lucretia. Shue reportedly beat his wife Estie so badly that a group of vigilantes dragged him out of bed one winter night and threw him through the ice in the Greenbrier River. It is unclear whether this incident occurred before or after the birth of their baby girl in February 1887. The marriage ended in divorce four years later, while Trout Shue was in the state penitentiary serving time for horse stealing.

 

 In June of 1894, Shue married again, this time to Lucy Ann Tritt, from near Alderson. They lived with his parents on Droop Mountain near Hillsboro, where Lucy died less than eight months later. There was no investigation, and the Pocahontas Times stated only that she died suddenly. Only later, when Shue was accused of murdering Zona, did four different stories about Lucy's death circulate among the community.

     After telling neighbors of her ghostly visits from Zona, Mary Jane Heaster visited the Honorable John Alfred Preston, the prosecuting attorney for Greenbrier County, and apparently presented enough troubling information that a court order was issued for the exhumation of the corpse. People who had viewed the corpse before it was originally buried had found it odd that the head was so loose that stuffing, a pillow and a folded sheet, had been placed in the coffin to keep it upright. Some folks noticed some discoloration on the right check. All noticed that Shue himself kept jealous watch over the body, and would let no one near it.

     Preston went to see Dr. Knapp, the physician who had examined the corpse. Knapp admitted that because the husband had exhibited such distress over anyone's touching Zona's body, that his examination had been cursory. Furthermore, Trout Shue had already dressed his wife himself, before Knapp got there, in a high-necked gown, with a big scarf around the neck. Preston and Knapp together agreed that an autopsy would clear things up, denying or confirming the suspicions of Mary Jane Heaster and others, and lifting suspicion from Shue if indeed he were innocent.

 

Three physicians participated in the autopsy. As is common practice in an autopsy, they examined Zona's stomach for poison, and checked the other vital organs of the chest and abdomen. Working around the head and neck, the doctors began to whisper. One of the doctors turned to Shue and said, "Well, Shue, we have found your wife's neck to have been broken." The Pocahontas Times reported that: "On the throat were the marks of fingers indicating that she had been choken [sic]; that the neck was dislocated between the first and second vertebrae. The ligaments were torn and ruptured. The windpipe had been crushed at a point in front of the neck." Shue was charged with murder, and jailed in Lewisburg to await trial.

     Preston and his assistant Henry Gilmer set about building a case against Shue. Shue continued to say from jail, as he had earlier, "They will not be able to prove I did it." He was defended by William Parkes Rucher and James P.D. Gardner. Their efforts to gather witnesses, alibis and other evidence of his innocence must have been discouraging, for on May 20, 1897, the Pocahontas Times reported, "Trout Shue É now in jail awaiting trial for the murder of his wife, has threatened to kill himself." Although Preston's case was based entirely on circumstantial evidence, the jury convicted Shue of murder and sentenced him to prison.

     Central to the story of the Greenbrier Ghost is whether it was in fact the ghost story that led to the jury's decision to find Shue guilty of murder. The only part of the trial transcript available today is Mary Jane Heaster's impassioned story about the appearance of her daughter for four nights in a row, telling of Shue's wringing her neck and throwing her downstairs. The "ghost testimony" was brought out by the defense, presumably to call into question the sanity and reliability of Mary Jane Heaster. At the end of the trial, Shue took the stand, rambled on for an entire afternoon, and appealed to the jury "to look into his face and then say if he was guilty." This made, according to the Independent account, an "unfavorable impression."

 

 The jury returned a verdict of guilty after only one hour and ten minutes of deliberation. The accounts in the Independent make clear that Shue was convicted of the murder of his third wife on circumstantial evidence, and not because of a "ghost's testimony." He was sentenced to life in the state prison. Following a foiled lynching attempt a few days later, he was taken by train to the state prison in Moundsville, where he died on the first of March, 1900.

     Believing in a rational world where the dead stay dead, I wondered where Mrs. Heaster got the ghost story, and why she invented or dreamed up such a thing. Why weren't the suspicions of her neighbors and her own misgivings enough to take to the prosecuting attorney? Why did she need the drama of a ghost? Mrs. Heaster lived until 1916, and never recanted her story.

     My assumption finally was that she knew the blacksmith to be clever, unprincipled, and persuasive. If he'd murdered once, he could murder again. Perhaps she feared that if no one validated her accusations, Shue would prove extremely dangerous. So pretending to receive the news directly from Zona, she could appeal to the superstitions of her mountaineer neighbors and get a lot of public attention. As it turned out, she didn't need the ghost story, for Shue was convicted, according to every account, strictly on earthly considerations, without any unearthly ghosts.

     My research was more or less complete. I was satisfied that the ghost story was merely an ingenious method by which a canny woman contrived to seek justice for her daughter's murder. Then late one night, I received a phone call which, I feel, shows what really happened in the case of the Greenbrier Ghost. And for this last bit of information, you'll have to read the book.

bottom of page